By Erin Smith
With federal government shutdown having come to an end, the federal courts have reopened for business. The fifth case in the hog farm nuisance lawsuits, which was originally scheduled to begin jury selection on Tuesday, January 8, 2019, will now begin on Thursday, January 31, 2019.
The nuisance lawsuits that have been filed against Murphy-Brown, LLC claim to target hog farms owned by the company. This lawsuit will be the fifth case out of 26 nuisance lawsuits that have been filed against the company in the Federal District Court for the Eastern Division in Wake County.
The plaintiffs’ attorney Michael Kaeske, from Texas, is alleging once more in court documents the plaintiffs cannot enjoy the use of their property due to an abundance of flies and smells which he claims are the result of the hog farm. In addition, court records also list complaints about truck traffic which have been attributed to the farm.
The court records show the Joey Carter Hog Farm located near the town of Beaulaville in Duplin County listed as a defendant along with Murphy-Brown, LLC. According to the court documents, the farm produces 4,740 feeder to finish hogs.
Attorneys representing Murphy-Brown LLC argue that the plaintiffs in the case have failed to show any facts to the court that support their argument. In a motion to dismiss the case, which ultimately failed, attorneys for Murphy-Brown LLC argued the hog operations contracted with Murphy-Brown LLC operated without violations in 2011 and 2012. The farm in question in this case is not owned by Murphy-Brown LLC, but rather it is owned by Joey Carter, who is a contract grower for Murphy-Brown, LLC.
Mark Anderson also wrote, “Far from acknowledging Murphy-Brown’s compliance with regulatory and legal standards, Plaintiffs’ Complaint is a diatribe against the hog industry in general and its perceived impact on society and the environment. As support for their claims, plaintiffs rely on various studies or reports critical of Concentrated Animal Feeding Operations (“CAFOs”) as part of a larger effort to eliminate CAFOs altogether.”
The first three hog farm nuisance lawsuits have ended in large payouts to the plaintiffs. The fourth lawsuit, which was overseen by Judge David Faber, saw another verdict for the plaintiffs in the case, but they did not receive a large payout.Share: